Best Restaurants In Siesta Key Village

Siesta Key Village is a very versatile food hub. Here you can get dishes from different cuisines and they are mainly focused on seafood. In case you are not interested in seafood or have health hazards, you can get other options too.

From European Cuisine to Mexican Cuisine, you can enjoy all in Siesta Key. Go through the post and hopefully, it will help you to organize your trip to Siesta Key Village a bit more.

Breakfast Restaurant In Siesta Key Village

If you don’t want to travel to places or to start your morning without great coffee and food, then here are some places we suggest you take a look at. 

Lelu Coffee Lounge

Even though it is always suggested to have a heavy breakfast, if you are in a hangover or just craving some coffee with pastry, then you must visit Lelu Coffee Lounge. They make the best coffee with freshly grounded beans and locally pasteurized milk. You can get vegan milk too.

Lelu Coffee Lounge

With the coffee, you can pair up their homemade pastry and dessert. It is open all day long. But morning is a bit of rush hour. The lounge is in a historic building, which can boost your mood. 

Another Broken Egg Cafe

In Another Broken Egg Cafe, you are going to get both a fancy and traditional breakfast. You can order any regular omelet or pancakes and still the taste will feed your heart.

Another Broken Egg Cafe
Another Broken Egg Cafe

On the other hand, if you are looking for a fancy breakfast, you can go with Lobster and Brie Omelet, Chicken and Waffles, Cookie Dough Waffles, or lemon-crusted French Toast. You can never go wrong with these dishes. 

Italian Restaurant In Siesta Key Village

Italian food in America is often the go-to food, like pizza. If you are craving some authentic Italian food in Siesta Key Village, here are two places you can go to.

Flavio’s Brick Oven and Bar

Italian foods are always comfort food. To get that authentic homemade Italian food, you need to go to Flavio’s Brick Oven and Bar. They have a variety of Pizzas. On the menu, you can get authentic pizzas like Four Cheese and White Pizza, Prosciutto e Arugula, and Pizza Del Giorno. They are baked in a brick oven. 

Flavio’s Brick Oven and Bar
Flavio’s Brick Oven and Bar

In the list of pasta, their specialization is in Lasagna Al Forno, Linguine Alle Bongole, Paccheri Alla Norma, Veal Saltimbocca, Piccata Di Vitello, and more. You can also get Antipasti dishes. 

Cafe Gabbiano

For a fine dining experience with Italian dishes in Siesta Key Village, you should go to Cafe Gabbiano. They bring Italian food to your plate by an Italian Chef from Napa Valley..

Cafe Gabbiano
Cafe Gabbiano

The most renowned dishes of Cafe Gabbiano are Pollo Momma Lucia, Costolette di Vitello Parmigiana, and Lasagna Bolognese. They also serve crepes, Pollo, Pesce, and antipasti dishes. You can never go wrong with any of their dishes.

French Restaurant In Siesta Key Village

French food is always a delicacy for the American food palate. In Siesta Key village, you find a few places to enjoy French food. 

Bonjour French Cafe

Whether it’s breakfast or lunch, Bonjour French Cafe has a menu for you. The restaurant is decorated with a French ambiance. There is French Art on the walls that you can buy.

Bonjour French Cafe
Bonjour French Cafe

You can enjoy a great brunch or a filling lunch in the place. They have outdoor seating too. On the menu, you can get French Crepes, Croissants, Sandwiches, and many more. If you are looking for healthy dishes, you can do with their fresh fruit bowls or fresh salads. 

Miguel’s Restaurant

If you are looking for fine dining in the village with French cuisine, then you must go to Miguel’s Restaurant. It is just on the side of the village, the whole atmosphere is decorated with warm light.

Miguel's Restaurant

Along with regular French dishes, you can even get vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free options. They have a separate menu for special occasions. So if you have any allergies or special requirements let the waiter your preference. 

American-Style Restaurants In Siesta Key Village 

There are lots of American restaurants in Siesta Key Village. Here are some top restaurants you will like.

Village Cafe

If you are looking for breakfast in Siesta Key Village with American Palate, then go to Village Cafe. You can have a traditional breakfast with pancakes, Belgium waffles, cinnamon rolls, Benedict, muffins, and more. 

Village Cafe
Village Cafe

In case you are looking for healthy food, you can try their oatmeal menu. Also, you can hop into the restaurant for brunch or lunch with sandwiches. 

Siesta Key Oyster Bar

Siesta Key Oyster Bar is one of the locals’ favorite restaurants. They have a bar serving delicious seafood. Their Oyster and Mussels dishes are a must try. You can also get Lobster, Fillet, Snow Crab, Atlantic Salmon, Scallops, and Risotto. If you don’t like seafood, you can go with beef and chicken dishes. 

Siesta Key Oyster Bar
Siesta Key Oyster Bar

They arrange an open mic night on Tuesdays, and they have live music every night. So you enjoy your food with music or even participate yourself. It is one of the best Siesta Key Village Seafood Restaurants. Moreover, it is a dog-friendly restaurant on the island.

The Old Salty Dog

The Florida favorite The Old Salty Dog has a branch in Siesta Key Village. They serve traditional American dishes. On the menu, you can get Nugget Basket, Mac’n Cheese, Mozzarella Stick, Mussels Dishes, and lots of Seafood items. 

The Old Salty Dog
The Old Salty Dog

All the food served is locally vendor and fresh. The demand for the restaurant is so high due to its pocket-friendliness that you can’t help but get fresh food. 

Mexican Restaurant In Siesta Key Village

Mexican foods are the ultimate topical food. It has spices and a lot of flavors. So, if you are also craving Mexican food in Siesta Key Village, then, here are a few you can go to. 

The Hub Baja Grill

The Hub Baja Grill is a very happy place with a Mexican vibe all over it. They have great indoor seating along with outdoor seating. The patio is covered and lighted. 

The Hub Baja Grill
The Hub Baja Grill

You can get grouper fish tacos, hand-made lobster bisque, and many more tropical dishes. Even they have a great list of beverages. One interesting part of dining in The Hub Baja Grill is the live music. Not only in the evening but all day long. 

Island House Tap & Grill

After the beach time, if you are craving a Mexican snack or a meal, then you can go to Island House Tap & Grill. It is just in the northern corner of the Village. 

Island House Tap & Grill
Island House Tap & Grill

For snacks, you can try their Duck Fat Fries, Calamari, I.H. Nachos, or Cheese Quesadilla. Also for a filling meal, you can get Salads, Mexican rice bowls, regular or seafood tacos, burgers, and more. If you are with kids, then try their kids’ menu. 

Also if you can’t dine in, then they take delivery orders. You can enjoy their food just by sitting on the beach.

Best Dessert Places In Siesta Key Village

Whether it is to finish off dining or you just love dessert, Siesta Key Village has a lot of options for you. Here are some places you can visit.

Made In Rome Organic Gelato

In Made In Rome Organic Gelato you are going to get the best Italian gelato. All the ingredients for making gelato here are certified organic. The restaurant is open till midnight, thus if you want to satisfy a late-night craving you can visit the place.

Made In Rome Organic Gelato
Made In Rome Organic Gelato

Their latest hiped gelato is Red Tide and Activated Charcoal Gelato. They have lots of options. You can also get Italian Espresso or other pastries. 

Kilwins Siesta Key

Kilwins Siesta Key is a new dessert place in Siesta Key Village. But they serve great desserts. You can try pastry cakes, fudges, gelatos, frozen yogurt, and ice creams. 

They make the product themselves from the locally sourced ingredients. Thus you get fresh products. 

Kilwins Siesta Key
Kilwins Siesta Key

Stefano Versace Gelato

It is one of the highly recommended gelato places in Siesta Key. They serve great Gelato and ice cream. If you are not looking for gelato or ice cream, you can try their cheesecake. You can never get wrong with their raspberry cheesecake. 

Stefano Versace Gelato
Stefano Versace Gelato

Siesta Key Village Restaurants On The Water

There are only a few restaurants in the village where you can get great food and a waterfront view. Here are some options you can take a look at. 

Ophelia’s On The Bay

If you are in the Village and willing to go just a small distance for great food with a mesmerizing view, then we ask you to go to Ophelia’s on the Bay. 

Ophelia's On The Bay
Ophelia’s On The Bay

It has a great view from which it seems like you are on the deck of a ship and having lunch or dinner. They make seasonal seafood, thus they have a rotating menu. But all the food is delicious and fresh. The environment is very relaxing. You can enjoy the sunset from there. 

The Old Salty Dog

With a great atmosphere, you can get some delicious food. It’s a Florida Favorite. You can get American cuisines like Nugget Basket, Grouper Reuben, Snow Crab Platter, Spicy Shrimp Mac n’ Cheese, and more. 

The Old Salty Dog
The Old Salty Dog

The Siesta Key branch is mostly expertized in seafood. They have a great menu of Soups and Salads, Tacos, Sandwiches, Burgers, and Hotdogs. Thus if you are a fan of The Old Salty Dog then visit the beach of Siesta Key Village. Also, your dog is going to have a relaxing time as they can accompany you in your dining. 

Beach Restaurants In Siesta Key Village

Most of the restaurants in Siesta Key Village are by the beach. They are just 5 to 6 minutes away. You can get a view of the beach from these restaurants. Here are some restaurants that you can take a look at.

The Cottage

When it comes to locals’ favorites, The Cottage comes at the top. They have a farm-to-table policy, by which they serve the freshest and finest food. They are specialized in seafood. But you can also get short ribs and roasted chicken. 

The Cottage
The Cottage

On the drink menu, you can get cocktails, wines, mocktails, and seasonal fruit drinks. From Tapas to sandwiches, all taste delightful. It is a must-visit place. Also, you can get a beach view. Also if you are visiting your pet, you can take it to the restaurant. 

Gilligan’s Island Bar & Grill

Gilligan’s Island Bar & Grill is decorated with a tropical theme. You will sit under a thatched roof. The restaurant is just a 4-minute walk from the beach. If you sit on the patio, you can enjoy the breeze from the sea. 

On the menu, you will get authentic Mexican food along with American sandwiches. The menu is mostly filled with seafood. But you can also get a chicken menu. All are great to taste. In the beverage, you can get cocktails, daiquiri, pina colada, and more. 

FAQs

Is Siesta Key a party spot?

Siesta Key is a great place to hang out after dark. There are lots of bars and clubs where you can enjoy a Cocktail, live music, late-night bites, and more. Even though it is not a traditional party place, you will still enjoy hanging out with your friends and enjoying Cocktail drinks.

Is Siesta Key better than Sarasota?

Sarasota is also a part of Siesta Key Island. Both places have lots of fun activities to do on and off the beach. They are just minutes away. So if you are in one place, we suggest you visit the other. 

Is Siesta Key expensive?

Siesta Key is the place where you can control the budget. Hotels that you want to stay, and where you want to dine in, have lots of options that you can choose from. Therefore, it is safe to say that you can visit Siesta Key on any budget.

Final Words

Traveling to any place becomes easier when you have an idea about where to stay and where to dine. In this post, we try to put some of the options available for you under different categories. 

If you are a foodie, then we suggest you visit all the places mentioned here. You will love their food and their ambiance at the same time.

Marina // Travel Enthusiast

Marina is a travel writer and beach enthusiast with years of experience exploring the world’s most stunning coastal destinations. With a degree in tourism and certification as a PADI scuba diving instructor and lifeguard, Maria has the expertise to provide valuable insights into beach safety, water sports, and ocean conservation. Her travel guides and articles on beach destinations have been published in top travel magazines, and she has worked with tourism boards and hotels to promote responsible travel practices. When she’s not writing, Maria can be found surfing, paddle boarding, or lounging on the beach with a good book.

Leave a Comment